QUESTION

Can i sue someone for the difference of my auto loan if insurance doesnt cover all costs?

Asked on Jun 14th, 2012 on Personal Injury - California
More details to this question:
I was recently in an accident where the other driver ran a red light and totaled my car. Well, my car was totaled and i didnt even have it for 2 months! So Allstate appraised my car and are paying for $13200 worth of damages however my loan was 15200 not including the $ 1000 my grandma put as a downpayment i understand the insurance cant do anything else but i thats why i feel the other driver should pay off the loan and pay another $1000 for a new car why should i have to suffer and pay for a car that i had for such a short amount of time when it wasnt my fault. I have also encountered neck shoulder and back pain from the incidentAm i correct for feeling this way? Should i follow through with this case?
Report Abuse

6 ANSWERS

Debt Collection Attorney serving Fresno, CA at Nunes Law, Inc.
Update Your Profile
This is a tragic situation that often happens when a minimal down payment is applied to a financed auto purchase. Many lenders offer "gap insurance" to cover situations such as this. The loan documents are usually the best source for determining the existence or at least the offering of gap insurance to the borrower. The rule of remedies for property damage is that the owner of the damaged property is entitled to repair or replacement value of the property, whichever is less. Most lenders require full or comprehensive coverage on financed automobiles to assure their security for the loan, i.e. the car is protected in cases of theft or loss. Often times when the repair cost exceeds a certain level, the insurance company will declare the vehicle a total loss and issue payment for the value to replace the vehicle. When the parties disagree on the value, they can either sue the responsible parties, not the insurance company, or Allstate was your insurance company for your claim, then make a demand for appraisal. The party challenging the offer should be prepared with evidence to show how the offer is too low. The appraisal process can be very expensive but the process will be governed by the terms of the Allstate policy. I always tell my clients to seek medical attention immediately if they believe they were injured in the accident. After that, they should make an appointment with a lawyer who handles personal injury matters in their area or the area of the accident's occurrence.
Answered on Jun 26th, 2012 at 12:53 PM

Report Abuse
Wage & Overtime Litigation Attorney serving San Diego, CA
Partner at Kased Law Group
4 Awards
You would not have run into this dilemma had you purchased GAP insurance to begin with; the carrier would have covered the difference between the amount financed at purchase and the total loss valuation. Have you tried negotiating with Allstate to increase the amount of its appraisal? If I have a client who is unsatisfied with an appraisal, I conduct my own independent valuation using online car valuation tools such as Kelley Blue Book (at kbb.com). I have had success getting adverse insurance companies to raise their total loss offers significantly in this manner. Also, make sure that Allstate has accounted for (in its appraisal) any after-market items you may have added to the vehicle after purchase (e.g., sophisticated sound system, custom rims, etc.). These items are sometimes overlooked and left out of the appraisal. Otherwise, I suppose you could bring a small claims action against the adverse driver to try to recover the $2,000 or so you are out. However, because Allstate's appraisal of your totaled vehicle is likely very close to what your vehicle was worth at the time of collision (accounting for two or so months of depreciation), I do not think you would prevail. Accordingly, I think your best bet is to (1) settle your property damage claim with Allstate for as much as you can get and (2) also pursue a bodily injury claim with Allstate.
Answered on Jun 26th, 2012 at 10:30 AM

Report Abuse
Car/Auto Accident Attorney serving Hacienda Heights, CA at Gary Lee Platt
Update Your Profile
First, what you can legally recover for damage to your car is the cost of repairs IF the care is not totalled (that is, the cost of repairs does not exceed the CURRENT market value of the vehicle). If the repair cost does exceed the current market value of your car, then the car is "totaled," and what you are entitled to is the reasonable market value of the vehicle at the time and place where it was damaged. That means, what you could reasonably hope to sell the car for at the time and place where it was damaged. Although it may seem unfair that you owe more than the car is worth, the car begins to depreciate the moment you drive it off the new car lot, and if you finance the car or are paying off a car loan with interest, you will pay far more for the car over time than you would if you bought it for cash. The defendant who you sue for damaging your car is not responsible for paying the interest and finance charges you incurred when you got the loan, only the value of the car. Second, if you are experiencing pain from the accident, you should seek medical attention immediately. You don't say how long ago the accident was, but if it was only a few days ago, you could have sustained some fairly serious injuries which could affect you for months or years to come if not treated. The longer the gap between the accident and the time you first seek treatment, the more likely the defendant's insurance company and its lawyers will succeed in arguing that you aren't seriously injured and only sought treatment to maximize your recovery in an insurance claim and lawsuit. Thus, if the accident was a month ago, or longer, unless you are experiencing very serious pain and symptoms of a verifiable injury (that is, either a broken bone or something that can be verified through a diagnostic study like an MRI or CAT Scan) you will have a hard time getting compensated for medical treatment and pain and suffering if you file an insurance claim or sue the other driver. If you have medical insurance and can obtain medical examination and treatmentif necessarywithout having to pay much or anything, you should do so immediately, and let the medical provider know you have been in an accident. Hiring a lawyer is also a good idea, if you can afford to do so. If you have verifiable injuries and there is insurance coverage for the defendant, you should have no problem finding a lawyer who will handle your case on a contingency basis, which means he/she will take a percentage of any recovery you may receive, and won't charge you any advance retainer fee.
Answered on Jun 26th, 2012 at 9:52 AM

Report Abuse
You can claim any of your losses against the negligent driver. If they don't have insurance it might be impossible to collect, but you have the right.
Answered on Jun 25th, 2012 at 6:35 PM

Report Abuse
When your car is totaled by another driver, the insurance company is only liable for the replacement value of the car, which is the value of the car on the day it was totaled, not how much the car was bought for.
Answered on Jun 25th, 2012 at 6:11 PM

Report Abuse
Personal Injury Attorney serving Beverly Hills, CA
Partner at Engelman Law, APC
You are correct. You should contact an attorney to discuss your case in detail.
Answered on Jun 25th, 2012 at 6:08 PM

Report Abuse

Ask a Lawyer

Consumers can use this platform to pose legal questions to real lawyers and receive free insights.

Participating legal professionals get the opportunity to speak directly with people who may need their services, as well as enhance their standing in the Lawyers.com community.

0 out of 150 characters